Hello dear
Welcome To Mama Tita's Pizza
At Mama Tita's Pizza, our story is rooted in a passion for authentic flavors and warm hospitality. Located in Commack, NY, we create a welcoming atmosphere where guests can enjoy not only our renowned pizzas but also a variety of delicious dishes, from baked ziti to savory appetizers like baked clams and chicken wings. Our commitment to exceptional service is evident in every meal, whether you dine in our cozy space, enjoy the vibrant outdoor seating, or opt for takeout. Join us at Mama Tita's Pizza, where every bite is a celebration and every visit feels like home.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
3 Topping Sicilian Pizza
$36.852 Topping Sicilian Pizza
$34.353 Topping Large Cheese Pizza
$33.65
2 Topping Large Cheese Pzza
$31.25Shrimp Pesto Pizza
$30.95Shrimp Parmigiana Pizza
$30.95
2 Topping Medium Cheese Pizza
$28.75Sicilian Pizza
$26.25Chicken & Broccoll Pizza
$25.95 About
Mama Tita's Pizza
Welcome to Mama Tita's Pizza, your new favorite spot for authentic pizza and fresh salads in Commack, NY! Located conveniently at 149 Veterans Memorial Hwy, this charming eatery offers a delightful culinary experience that caters to both pizza lovers and health-conscious diners. Whether you crave a classic slice or a wholesome salad wrap, Mama Tita's has something to satisfy every palate.
Highlights of Mama Tita's Pizza:
- Variety of Offerings: Mama Tita's Pizza isn't just about pizza. Their menu features an impressive array of options including delicious wraps, hearty heroes, and mouthwatering baked pasta dishes. The Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap is a standout, as noted by satisfied patrons.
- Commitment to Quality: Customers rave about the quality of the food here. From their freshly made pizzas to the carefully crafted heroes like the Chicken Cutlet Hero and Eggplant Hero, every dish is prepared with passion and attention to detail.
- Exceptional Service: Walk into Mama Tita's, and you’ll be greeted with warm smiles and friendly service. Reviews highlight the welcoming atmosphere, with patrons appreciating the personal touch that makes dining here enjoyable.
- Accessibility and Comfort: With clean facilities, ample parking, and outdoor seating under the umbrellas, Mama Tita's is accessible for everyone looking to have a pleasant meal.
Many guests have shared their love for the variety of pizzas available, with some specifically praising the Sicilian slice for its perfect sauce-to-cheese ratio and light texture. The Chicken Bacon Ranch slice is another favorite, often described as a deliciously unique take on traditional pizza. Furthermore, those with dietary restrictions will be pleased to know that Mama Tita's provides accommodations for allergies, making it a worry-free dining option.
However, it's not just the food that makes Mama Tita's a must-visit. The overall dining experience speaks volumes, with many customers noting the charming ambiance and cleanliness of the restaurant. As Emily R. suggests, the "excellent food comes with even better service," highlighting the owner's friendliness and attentive staff.
To sum it up, Mama Tita's Pizza in Commack promises a hearty meal rich in flavor and freshness. Whether you're stopping by for a quick slice or ordering a family meal to-go, you won't leave disappointed. Join the happy crowd and make your way to Mama Tita’s for pizza that's as delightful as its service!
Call for takeout at (631) 486-6682 or visit today for a taste of the good life!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ What a nice place Accommodations for allergy Accessible Parking Clean bathrooms AWESOMEpizza choices A must try right off highway Good taste excellent Clean restaurant ”
“ Great pizza, great service. Their chicken ceaser wrap is delish! Food always arrives on time. ”
“ Do yourself a favor an order the egg plant parm roll. It's amazing and has become a new family favorite. We've ordered takeout from here a few times and the pizza is really good. However, I don't love the mushroom topping because the mushrooms taste like they're the mushrooms from a can (I'd prefer fresh, but that's just me). I'll continue to order from here. ”
“ This is a nice little place. I've passed a number of times, but never stopped in. The wife and I remedied that today while we were waiting for tires to be put on our other car. As per usual, I got a plain slice and the Sicilian looked really good. My wife got the chicken bacon ranch. The regular slice could be a little thicker and a little crispier. However, there's a nice tang to the sauce. The sauce to cheese ratio is perfect. I can't complain about the taste. This Sicilian slice was excellent. Even though it was thick, there was something light about it. It didn't lay in my stomach afterwards. My wife really liked her chicken bacon ranch slice. I had a piece of it and it was excellent. It was almost like they had chicken nuggets on top. The service was amazing, super friendly, and he even brought her food over to our table, with legit plates with actual metal silverware. I would easily recommend stopping in for lunch. ”
“ Excellent food with even better service, ownership is very friendly! Cute little restaurant with lots of seating, including some outdoor tables with umbrellas! ”
“ Great food! Small little place a little hidden in shopping center. We had baked clams, fried calamari, chicken francaise, chicken Vesuvio and fettuccine Alfredo. ”
